Best Affordable Tudor Black Bay 54 & 58 Alternatives: 2025 Watch Guide

The Tudor Black Bay 54 and 58 are celebrated as some of the finest modern dive watches, blending vintage aesthetics with Swiss craftsmanship. However, with prices starting at $3,500, not everyone can—or wants to—spend that much. That's why many watch enthusiasts are searching for more affordable alternatives that maintain vintage dive watch charm without breaking the bank. Thankfully, many brands offer excellent homage watches that emulate the Black Bay’s spirit with their own unique twists at a fraction of the price.

In this 2025 guide, we explore the 17 best affordable alternatives to the Tudor Black Bay 54 and 58. These timepieces offer similar vintage-inspired designs, solid dive-ready specifications, and reliable movements, making them perfect for every dive watch enthusiasts on a budget.

Tudor Black Bay 58

[photo credit: TUDOR / www.tudorwatch.com]

What Makes the Tudor Black Bay 54 and 58 So Iconic?

Before diving into the alternatives, let’s understand what makes the BB54 and BB58 so desirable:

• Vintage-Inspired Aesthetic: Drawing from Tudor’s 1950s dive watch legacy, these models feature clean dials, snowflake hands, and domed crystals.

• Compact Case Sizes: The BB54 is 37mm, while the BB58 is 39mm—ideal for those who prefer smaller watches.

• High-Quality Finishing: With brushed and polished surfaces, both watches exude a luxurious feel.

• Reliable Movements: In-house COSC-certified calibers with 70-hour power reserves.

• Dive Watch Functionality: 200m water resistance, unidirectional bezels, and luminous markers.

Tudor Black Bay 54

[photo credit: TUDOR / www.tudorwatch.com]

Now, let’s look at the best homage options.

1. Glycine GL0396 Combat Sub 36

Brand Overview: Founded in 1914, Glycine is a Swiss brand known for its aviation and dive watches. It gained fame with the Airman line and continues to produce robust tool watches.

Synopsis: The GL0396 Combat Sub 36 delivers the classic diver aesthetic in a smaller case size, ideal for those seeking vintage proportions without sacrificing functionality.

[photo credit: GLYCINE / www.glycine-watch.ch]

Key Specs:

• Case Diameter: 36mm

• Case material: Stainless Steel

• Bezel material: Aluminum

• Movement: Automatic GL224 (ETA 2824 base)

• Movement Jewels: 26

• Water Resistance: 300 Meters

• Luminous Material: Swiss SuperLuminova

• Crystal: Sapphire

• Bezel: Unidirectional

• Bracelet: Stainless Steel

• Gender: Unisex

Price Range: $500–$1,275

2. Yema Superman Gilt CMM.10

Brand Overview: Yema is a French watch brand founded in 1948, known for its deep connection to motorsport and diving. The Superman line is its most iconic.

Synopsis: With vintage styling, gilt accents, and in-house CMM.10 movement, this Superman stands out as a French-made luxury homage to classic divers.

[photo credit: YEMA / yema.com]

Key Specs:

• Case Diameter: 39mm

• Case Material: 316L Stainless Steel

• Movement: Calibre Manufacture Morteau 10 (CMM.10)

• Power Reserve: 70 Hours

• Water Resistance: 300 Meters

• Luminous Material: Grade A Super-LumiNova

• Crystal: Double Dome Sapphire

• Bezel: Unidirectional Rotating

• Bracelet: Stainless Steel


Price Range: $850–$1,790

3. Nomadic Maraí 401 Classic Black and Gold

Brand Overview: Nomadic is a Belfast-based microbrand creating luxury-quality watches that pay homage to the city’s craftsmanship and maritime history.

Synopsis: The Maraí 401 blends Irish heritage with bold design. Its black and gold motif with domed crystal channels high-end vintage vibes.

[photo credit: NOMADIC / nomadicwatches.com]

Key Specs:

• Case Diameter: 40.5mm

• Case Material: 316L Stainless Steel

• Movement: Sellita SW200-1, Automatic, Self Winding

• Power Reserve: 41 Hours

• Water Resistance: 200 Meters

• Luminous Material: LUMINESCENCESuperLumiNova®, Green C3 

• Crystal: Domed Sapphire With Anti-Reflective Coating Inside

• Bezel: Ceramic Insert, Uni-Directional

• Bracelet: Stainless Steel, With Quick-Release Spring Bars


Price Range: $850–$1,249

4. Steinhart Ocean One Vintage Red

Brand Overview: Steinhart, a German brand founded in 2001, is known for offering Swiss-powered homage watches with great specs at reasonable prices.

Synopsis: The Ocean One Vintage Red nods to the iconic 1970s Submariner “Red Sub,” blending vintage design cues with modern reliability.

[photo credit: STEINHART / www.steinhartwatches.de]

Key Specs:

• Case Diameter: 42mm

• Case Material: 316L Stainless Steel

• Movement: ETA 2824-2/SW200, Automatic, Self Winding 

• Movement Jewels: 25/26

• Water Resistance: 300 Meters

• Luminous Material: Super Luminova Old Radium, Vintage

• Crystal: Medium Domed Sapphire With Double Anti-Reflecting Coatings On The Interior Side

• Bezel: Stainless Steel, Inlay Black Aluminum 

• Bracelet: Stainless Steel, With Safety Deployment Clasp


Price Range: $500–$600

5. Seiko SPB147 Prospex Sea

Brand Overview: A giant in watchmaking, Seiko is globally respected for its innovation, durability, and affordability across all price segments.

Synopsis: Part of Seiko’s 1965 heritage diver revival, the SPB147 combines a vintage look with modern materials and a reliable in-house movement.

[photo credit: SEIKO / www.seikowatches.com]

Key Specs:

• Case Diameter: 40.5mm

• Case Material: Stainless Steel

• Movement: Seiko 6R35

• Power Reserve: Approx. 70 Hours

• Movement Jewels: 24

• Water Resistance: 200 Meters

• Luminous Material: LumiBrite

• Crystal: Curved Sapphire

• Bezel: Unidirectional

• Strap: Silicone Dive Strap


Price Range: $800–$1,000

6. H.G.P. Diver 200M Mecaquartz Commando

Brand Overview: H.G.P. is a boutique brand focused on rugged, value-driven tool watches, particularly mecaquartz-powered divers.

Synopsis: This Commando edition mixes military styling with quartz-mechanical hybrid technology for budget-friendly reliability.

[photo credit: H.G.P. / www.hgp-watches.com]

Key Specs:

• Case Diameter: 38.5mm

• Case Material: 316L Stainless Steel

• Movement: Seiko VH31

• Water Resistance: 200 Meters

• Luminous Material: "Old Radium" Super-LumiNova® 

• Crystal: Sapphire

• Bezel: 120-click Unidirectional

• Bracelet: 316L Stainless Steel, With Quick-Release Spring-Bars And Solid Deployment Clasp


Price Range: $300–$350

7. NTH Barracuda Vintage Black Date BoR

Brand Overview: NTH is a U.S.-based microbrand celebrated for producing high-quality vintage-style divers with modern specs. Unfortunately, in 2024 NTH has ceased watch production and ended all business operations.

Synopsis: The Barracuda features strong vintage cues, excellent lume, and robust specs, all packed into a slim 11.5mm case.

[photo credit: NTH / nthwatches.com]

Key Specs:

• Case Diameter: 40mm

• Movement: Miyota 9015 (Automatic)

• Power Reserve: 40 Hours

• Movement Jewels: 24

• Water Resistance: 300 Meters

• Crystal: Double Domed Sapphire Glass With An AR Coating

• Bezel: 120-Click, Unidirectional 

• Bezel Material: Steel With DLC Coating

• Bracelet: Stainless Steel, Beads-of-Rice (BoR) Style


Price Range: $600–$750

8. Lorier Neptune Series IV

Brand Overview: Lorier is a New York-based microbrand founded by a husband-wife duo, known for vintage-inspired mechanical watches at accessible prices.

Synopsis: The Neptune Series IV is a sleek and wearable diver that nails the retro look with modern performance—no date, full character.

[photo credit: LORIER / www.lorierwatches.com]

Key Specs:

• Case Diameter: 39mm

• Case Material: 316L Marine-Grade Stainless Steel

• Movement: Miyota 90S5, Automatic

• Power Reserve: 42 Hours

• Water Resistance: 200 Meters

• Luminous Material: Superluminova BGW9 Luminous

• Crystal: Dome Hesalite

• Bezel: 120-Click, Unidirectional

• Bracelet: 316L Marine-Grade Stainless Steel With Solid Endlinks And Push-Button Clasp


Price Range: $450-499

9. VANDAAG Tiefsee Automatic - Gold-Black

Brand Overview: VANDAAG is a young German brand delivering Bauhaus-inspired and vintage-style timepieces with strong value-for-money appeal.

Synopsis: The Tiefsee Gold-Black combines modern German craftsmanship with classic diver styling, ideal for dressier aquatic adventures.

[photo credit: VANDAAG / www.vandaag.de]

Key Specs:

• Case Diameter: 41.5 mm

• Case Material: 316L Stainless Steel

• Movement: Miyota 8215, Automatic

• Power Reserve: 40 Hours

• Movement Jewels: 21

• Water Resistance: 200 Meters

• Luminous Material: Nemoto LumiNova® NCW1000 Resp. Beige Luminescent In Blue And Green 

• Crystal: Sapphire With 2-Fold Anti-Reflective Coating

• Bezel: Stainless Steel With Ceramic Inlay, Uni-directional, 120-Clicks

• Bracelet: Solid 3-Link 316L Stainless Steel Bracelet With Solid Folding Buckle 


Price Range: $350–$450

10. Baltic Aquascaphe Classic Black Gilt

Brand Overview: Baltic is a French microbrand producing minimalist yet beautifully vintage watches with premium specs and retro vibes.

Synopsis: The Aquascaphe’s gilt dial and compact case are tailor-made for lovers of old-school dive watches. Great finishing, great feel.

[photo credit: BALTIC / baltic-watches.com]

Key Specs:

• Case Diameter: 39mm

• Case Material: 316L Stainless Steel

• Movement: Miyota 9039, Automatic

• Power Reserve: 42 Hours

• Movement Jewels: 24

• Water Resistance: 200 Meters

• Luminous Material: Super-Luminova®: C1

• Crystal: Double Dome Sapphire

• Bezel: Sapphire Insert, Uni-Directional, 120-Clicks

• Bracelet: Rubber Strap Or Steel Beads-of-Rice Bracelet


Price Range: $600–$650

11. Charlie Paris Concordia Automatic Dune

Brand Overview: Charlie Paris is a French watchmaker blending elegant design with utility, creating timepieces that reflect modern French style.

Synopsis: The Concordia Dune captures a sense of adventure with warm tones, tool-watch capability, and strong Parisian aesthetics.

[photo credit: CHARLIE PARIS / charlie-paris.com]

Key Specs:

• Case Diameter: 40mm

• Case Material: 316L Stainless Steel

• Movement: Soprod P024, Swiss, Automatic

• Power Reserve: 40 Hours

• Movement Jewels: 25

• Water Resistance: 300 Meters

• Crystal: Sapphire

• Bezel: Unidirectional Rotating With Eloxed Aluminum Insert

• Strap: Stainless Steel, Leather Or Nylon


Price Range: $850–$995

12. Christopher Ward C65 Aquitaine GMT

Brand Overview: Christopher Ward is a British watchmaker that offers Swiss-made watches with fresh design and strong value.

Synopsis: The C65 Aquitaine GMT blends vintage explorer looks with GMT functionality and exceptional fit-and-finish.

[photo credit: Christopher Ward / www.christopherward.com]

Key Specs:

• Case Diameter: 41mm

• Case Material: Stainless Steel

• Movement: Sellita SW330-2

• Power Reserve: 56 Hours

• Movement Jewels: 25

• Water Resistance: 200 Meters

• Luminous Material: Super-LumiNova® Grade X1 BL Light Old Radium

• Crystal: Anti-Reflective Sapphire

• Bezel: Bi-Directional, Stainless Steel, Sapphire Insert

• Bracelet: Marine-Grade Stainless Steel, Micro-Adjustable Ratchet Clasp, Quick-Release System


Price Range: $1,250–$1,610

13. Geckota G-02

Brand Overview: UK-based Geckota started by crafting straps and evolved into offering distinctive timepieces inspired by vintage tool watches.

Synopsis: The G-02 offers vintage military styling with compact proportions and strong lume, ideal for budget-conscious collectors.

[photo credit: Geckota / www.geckota.com]

Key Specs:

• Case Diameter: 40mm

• Movement: ETA 2824

• Power Reserve: 38-42 Hours

• Movement Jewels: 17

• Water Resistance: 200 Meters

• Luminous Material: Super-LumiNova BGW9

• Crystal: Flat Sapphire

• Bezel: 120-Click, Unidirectional, Epoxy Resin Finish

• Strap: Stainless Steel, Leather Or Rubber


Price Range: $350–$585

14. GINAULT Ocean-Rover

Brand Overview: Ginault is an American watch brand that hand-assembles watches in the U.S. using premium components. Known for their extreme attention to detail, Ginault produces high-end homage watches often compared favorably to Rolex and Tudor models.

Synopsis: The Ocean-Rover is widely regarded as one of the highest-quality Tudor Black Bay 58 homages. From its finishing and bracelet articulation to its chronometer-level accuracy, it offers the closest experience to wearing a luxury Swiss diver at a fraction of the price.

[photo credit: GINAULT / ginault.com]

Key Specs:

• Case Diameter: 40mm

• Case Material: 316L Stainless Steel

• Movement: Ginault Caliber 7275

• Power Reserve: 38 Hours

• Water Resistance: 300 Meters

• Luminous Material: Ginault’s Proprietary “Gold Sand” Luminescent Pigment

• Crystal: Sapphire Crystal With Date Magnifier

• Bezel: 120-Click, Unidirectional

• Bracelet: 20mm stainless steel Oyster-style


Price Range: $1,000–$1,499

15. Oris Divers Sixty-Five

Brand Overview: Founded in 1904, Oris is a renowned Swiss independent watchmaker celebrated for mechanical-only timepieces that blend heritage charm with contemporary reliability. Known for its dedication to sustainability and robust craftsmanship, Oris is a mainstay in the world of high-quality, value-packed Swiss watches.

Synopsis: The Oris Divers Sixty-Five is a vintage-inspired diver that embodies the spirit of the 1960s with modern Swiss craftsmanship. This timepiece stands out with its warm gilt accents, polished case, and domed crystal, offering both retro flair and dependable performance. It’s the perfect choice for those who want a heritage dive watch with a touch of elegance.

[photo credit: ORIS / www.oris.ch]

Key Specs:

• Case Diameter: 40mm

• Case Material: Stainless Steel

• Movement: ORIS 733, Automatic 

• Power Reserve: 38 Hours

• Water Resistance: 100 Meters

• Crystal: Sapphire, Domed On Both Sides, Anti-Reflective Coating Inside

• Bezel: Unidirectional Rotating

• Bracelet: Stainless Steel


Price Range: $1,000–$2,500

16. San Martin BB Diver SN0138-G Watch

Brand Overview: San Martin is a Chinese microbrand well-regarded for its homages to iconic Swiss divers, delivering exceptional build quality at low prices.

Synopsis: This BB homage is a dead ringer for the Tudor Black Bay 58, with top-tier finishing, sapphire crystal, and ceramic bezel—all at a fraction of the price.

[photo credit: San Martin / sanmartinwatches.com]

Key Specs:

• Case Diameter: 39mm

• Case Material: 316L Stainless Steel

• Movement: NH35, Automatic

• Power Reserve: 41 Hours

• Movement Jewels: 24

• Water Resistance: 200 Meters

• Luminous Material: BGW-X1 Blue Lume And C3 Green Lume

• Crystal: Sapphire Crystal With AR Coating

• Bezel: 120-Clicks, Unidirectional, Ceramic Bezel Insert

• Bracelet: 316L Solid Stainless Steel 3-link Bracelet, Extension Folding Clasp


Price Range: $200–$399

Get the price on Amazon here. 

17. San Martin 6200 SN0004-G Mechanical

Brand Overview: San Martin’s focus on precision manufacturing and homage design makes it a strong contender in the affordable luxury market.

Synopsis: Inspired by early Submariners, the 6200 offers a no-date 38mm tool diver experience with vintage proportions and bulletproof reliability.

[photo credit: San Martin / sanmartinwatches.com]

Key Specs:

• Case Diameter: 38mm

• Case Material: 316L Stainless Steel

• Movement: NH35A, Automatic

• Power Reserve: 41 Hours

• Movement Jewels: 24

• Water Resistance: 200 Meters

• Luminous Material: Retro Luminous Effect SLN C3 Green Light/ BGW-9 Blue Light

• Crystal: Sapphire Crystal With AR Coating

• Bezel: Upgraded 120 Clicks Unidirectional, Ceramic Top Ring

• Bracelet: 316L Solid Stainless Steel, New Fly Adjustable Clasp, Folding Clasp With Safety


Price Range: $248–$350

Conclusion

If you admire the look and feel of the Tudor Black Bay 54 or 58 but need a more accessible price point, these 17 alternatives deliver exceptional style, heritage vibes, and reliable specs. Whether you lean toward microbrands, Japanese icons, or European craftsmanship, there’s a timepiece here to match your wrist and wallet alike.

The Tudor Black Bay 54 or 58 set a high standard in affordable luxury dive watches with their vintage charm, robust construction, and versatile style. Luckily, a wide array of brands—ranging from historic Swiss makers to nimble microbrands—offer alternatives that capture much of that magic for less.

From Glycine’s military heritage to the fresh design approaches of Lorier and Baltic, these 17 watches provide a variety of styles, movements, and price points to suit every dive watch fan. Whether you want a compact size, a unique bezel, or a GMT complication, these options bring you close to the Black Bay’s spirit without the premium price tag.

Homage watches let you experience the design language of iconic pieces without spending thousands. The timepieces in our guide deliver great vintage aesthetics, respectable mechanical movements, and dive-ready specs.

For many collectors and enthusiasts, these affordable alternatives aren’t just compromises—they’re standouts in their own right.

Recommended for you:

- Top 5 Affordable Swiss Watches in 2025

- Top 5 Omega Wristwatches You Need to Know in 2025

- What Watches Do Celebrities Wear?