Tudor Black Bay 58 Alternatives (Part-2)

The Tudor Black Bay 58 has become a modern icon in the world of dive watches — combining vintage charm, superb finishing, and dependable performance. Its balanced 39 mm case and gilt dial details evoke the golden era of dive watch design. However, not every enthusiast wants (or can justify) the $4,000+ price tag.

That’s where carefully chosen Tudor Black Bay 58 alternatives come in. These watches don’t simply imitate; they reinterpret the classic diver’s aesthetic with their own unique character, movements, and price points.

In Part 1 of this series, we explored a diverse lineup of homages and alternatives. Now, in Part 2, we’re highlighting five exceptional timepieces — from established Swiss makers to rising independents — that deliver vintage diver charm and contemporary specs, often at a fraction of the cost. Altogether, our guide now features a noble total of 22 BB58 alternatives. Impressive, isn’t it?

Be sure to read the Part-1 of this article here: Best Affordable Tudor Black Bay 54 & 58 Alternatives

Whether you’re after Swiss precision, independent flair, or a gold-accented statement piece, these Black Bay 58 alternatives for 2025 deserve your attention.

Certina DS Action Diver 43 mm Powermatic 80

Brand Background: Certina, founded in 1888 in Grenchen, Switzerland, has long been associated with reliable tool watches. Known for its Double Security (DS) concept introduced in 1959, Certina builds rugged, Swiss-made watches that meet ISO 6425 standards without luxury markups.

[photo credit: www.certina.com]

Key Specs:

• Movement: ETA Powermatic 80 automatic (80-hour power reserve)

• Case Size: 43 mm stainless steel

• Water Resistance: 300 m / 1000 ft

• Crystal: Sapphire

• Bezel: Unidirectional, titanium with ceramic insert

• Bracelet: Steel with diver’s extension

Estimated Price: $1,200 – $1,400 USD

Price on Amazon
Synopsis: The DS Action Diver offers serious dive credentials and impressive value, making it one of the strongest contenders among affordable Black Bay 58 alternatives. While it’s larger than the Tudor at 43 mm, its sleek profile, ceramic bezel options, and Powermatic 80 movement bring Swiss engineering within reach. For enthusiasts who prefer a bolder presence on the wrist without compromising heritage or quality, this Certina is a top pick.

Monterey Watch Co. Dark Bayou EM

Brand Background: Monterey Watch Co. is an American microbrand inspired by classic watch designs from the 50s - 60s, aiming to blend timeless style with modern functionality, quality components and affordability. Known for small-batch production and vintage-infused tool watches, the brand has been gaining traction among collectors looking for individuality.

[photo credit: montereywatches.com]

Key Specs:

• Movement: Automatic Seiko NH35A

• Case Size: 40 mm

• Water Resistance: 100 m

• Crystal: Sapphire crystal

• Bezel: Black ceramic bezel insert with lumed pip / rose gold marker and numerals

• Dial: Matte black with gold accents

Estimated Price: $300 – $350 USD

Synopsis: The Dark Bayou EM nails the vintage diver aesthetic with its warm gilt details and svelte 40 mm case — dimensions that echo the Black Bay 58’s wrist-friendly proportions. The automatic Seiko NH35A movement offers reliable performance, while its thoughtful design language feels authentic rather than derivative. For collectors who appreciate independent watchmaking and a more intimate brand story, Monterey delivers plenty of charm.

Méraud Bonaire “Onyx Black”

Brand Background: Méraud Watch Co., based in Belgium, merges mid-century styling with modern construction. The brand quickly built a following for its Bonaire model — a love letter to 1960s dive watches, crafted with meticulous attention to detail.

[photo credit: meraud-watches.com]

Key Specs:

• Movement: Swiss made G100 La Joux-Perret automatic

• Case Size: 40 mm stainless steel

• Water Resistance: 200 m

• Crystal: Top Hat Sapphire

• Bezel: Unidirectional acrylic bezel filled with luminescent material

• Dial: Glossy black with Swiss SUPER-LUMINOVA®

Estimated Price: $1,000 – $1,200 USD

Synopsis: The Bonaire “Onyx Black” channels vintage vibes with aplomb — from its gilt dial to the slim profile and sapphire crystal. The G100 self-winding movement brings Swiss reliability with 68-hour power reserve, while the finishing punches well above its price bracket. It’s one of the closest spiritual companions to the Tudor Black Bay 58 on this list, offering both authentic vintage aesthetics and modern-day refinement.

Rado Captain Cook Hrithik Roshan Special Edition

Brand Background: Rado, a member of the Swatch Group, has been pushing design boundaries since 1917. Known for its use of high-tech ceramics and distinctive aesthetics, the brand’s Captain Cook collection revives its 1960s diver heritage with contemporary luxury.

[photo credit: www.rado.com]

Key Specs:

• Movement: Rado calibre R734 automatic, 80-hour power reserve

• Case Size: 43 mm

• Water Resistance: 300 m

• Crystal: Sapphire with anti-reflective coating on both sides

• Bezel: Plasma High-Tech Ceramic Stainless steel / PVD

• Bracelet: Matt plasma high-tech ceramic outer links and polished plasma high-tech ceramic middle links

Estimated Price: $4,000 – $4,500 USD

Price on Amazon
Synopsis: This special edition Captain Cook adds star power and refined finishing to the lineup. With its high-tech ceramic bezel, long power reserve, and interchangeable strap system, Rado offers a modern, luxurious twist on the vintage diver. While priced higher than others on this list, it’s still a compelling Tudor alternative for those who want premium materials and Swiss prestige.

Bremont Supermarine 300 m Date Bi-Colour

Brand Background: Bremont is a British watchmaker founded in 2002, renowned for aviation and military timepieces. In recent years, the brand has expanded into dive watches with the Supermarine collection, combining rugged engineering and classic British styling.

[photo credit: bremont.com]

Key Specs:

• Movement: Modified Calibre 11 1/2’’’ BE-92AV

• Case Size: 40 mm 904L stainless steel and rose gold

• Water Resistance: 300 m

• Crystal: Domed anti-reflective, scratch resistant sapphire

• Bezel: 18ct rose gold capped knurled edged uni-directional dive bezel with brown aluminium insert

• Bracelet: Stainless steel bracelet with micro adjustment feature

Estimated Price: $4,500 – $5,500 USD

Synopsis: The Bremont Supermarine 300 m Date Bi-Colour brings a refined yet robust alternative to the Black Bay 58. Its 25 jewels movement with 50-hour power reserve, Glucydur balance, Anachron balance spring, and Nivaflex 1 mainspring, 18ct rose gold accents, and British engineering give it a distinctive personality that stands apart from Swiss homages. For those who want a statement piece that blends luxury with tool-watch DNA, this Bremont hits the mark.

Comparison Table — Tudor Black Bay 58 Alternatives

Model	Movement	WR	Case	Price (USD)	Notable Features
Certina DS Action Diver	Powermatic 80 Auto	300 m	43 mm	$1,200 – $1,400	ISO 6425, ceramic bezel
Monterey Dark Bayou EM	Seiko NH35A	100 m	40 mm	$300 – $350	Ceramic bezel, microbrand charm
Méraud Bonaire “Onyx Black”	G100 La Joux-Perret	200 m	40 mm	$1,000 – $1,200	Acrylic bezel, top hat sapphire crystal
Rado Captain Cook Special	Calibre R734	300 m	43 mm	$4,000 – $4,500	Plasma High-Tech Ceramic Stainless steel / PVD
Bremont Supermarine Bi-Colour	BE-92AV	300 m	40 mm	$4,500 – $5,500	Bi-metal design, domed anti-reflective sapphire crystal

FAQ — Tudor Black Bay 58 Alternatives

Q1: Are these watches direct homages or just inspired alternatives?

👉 Most of these models are inspired alternatives, not direct copies. They share vintage diver proportions, gilt details, and robust specs, but each brings its own design language.

Q2: Which is closest in size to the Tudor Black Bay 58?

👉 The Monterey Dark Bayou EM and Méraud Bonaire are both 40 mm, making them the closest in dimensions to the Black Bay 58’s 39 mm case.

Q3: Which offers the best value under $1,000?

👉 The Certina DS Action Diver stands out for its Swiss movement, 300 m water resistance, and ISO certification.

Q4: Are these watches suitable for actual diving?

👉 Yes. Most models we listed here offer 300 m or less water resistance, with screw-down crowns and robust construction suitable for recreational diving.

Q5: How do these compare to Tudor in terms of finishing?

👉 Tudor still leads in fine finishing and heritage branding, but brands like Rado, and Bremont offer distinctive alternatives with solid engineering and unique character.

Conclusion

The Tudor Black Bay 58 may reign as a modern classic, but these five watches prove that there are compelling alternatives across different price points and styles.

• Certina offers rugged Swiss tool watch value.

• Monterey and Méraud bring independent charm and vintage proportions.

• Rado infuses luxury materials and modern versatility.

• Bremont provides a British twist with bi-metal elegance.

Whether you’re building a collection, seeking your first serious diver, or simply want a distinctive alternative, these watches show that the Black Bay 58 aesthetic can be experienced in many forms — sometimes for less, sometimes with a different twist, but always with passion for fine watchmaking.